The HTRC

The Homeowners & Trades Resource Center

Brought to you by:

You are here: Home / Common Sense Building / Common Sense Building: Don’t just jump on the bandwagon

Common Sense Building: Don’t just jump on the bandwagon

28/08/2012 by SLS Leave a Comment

Contractors rightfully get a bad rap sometimes for not wanting to change or embrace new technologies. “I have been doing it this way for years & never had an issue.” Some that do embrace change have learned the hard way that it is best to tread carefully after being bitten by some new product that fails causing 100’s of houses to be redone. It can be a fine line sometimes, deciding when a concept or product is really ready for market and that they can successfully install it properly without issues.

On the other hand, many in the fields of building science, green building, energy efficiency, or sustainability on the other hand it is all about moving forward as fast as one can. Moving forward is good, but abandoning common sense just because all the big kids are going “this is the best thing since sliced bread” isn’t.

Bandwagon #1 – The Mini-Split craze

Starting off our list is this post by Roger Normand on GBA which struck me as a little shortsighted & naïve…

Goodbye radiant floor…

Though we never really knew you, we are sad to see you go away. Our original vision included radiant floor heating. Though we’ve never lived in a home with radiant floors, we had read numerous articles celebrating its comfortable, silent, even heat with no blowing air currents. According to many articles we’ve read, it’s also a good match to the output temperature of a solar thermal system, which is some 30 degrees below the input temperature for baseboard radiators…

Ductless minisplits are all the rage

Alas, it seemed most articles we read about heating/cooling a PassivHaus or other very tightly insulated homes relied on ductless minisplit systems. These systems consist of a condensing unit outside, connected via a small copper tube that circulates refrigerant to an indoor wall-mounted blower unit. The indoor component is touted as being whisper quiet. Some manufacturers claim their units can heat effectively down to a very cold -13 degrees Fahrenheit outdoor temperature… (Yes he lives in Maine so -13 is a concern)

Fortunately, unlike others that simply just jump on, he is not completely naïve as he is having heat load calculations being done on his 4000 SF dream house (including the basement) & he is also “dubious of its prowess when the thermometer plummets outside” (which quite frankly he should be). Are ductless mini-splits a good solution in many cases – yes they can be. Are they the only answer – not by a long shot & it sounds like him & his wife are going to be making some interesting trade-offs to maybe save a buck or two & hop aboard the bandwagon express.

Besides, one can’t really beat this as a segue into our next two articles which are going to deal exclusively with radiant floor heating. The first we are handing off to our good friend Todd Vendituoli of The Building Blox who not only provided the picture below but is going to cover how one is installed & some of the benefits he sees. This will be followed up by me on why it is on our list & worthy of consideration even if you live in the southern climate.

Bandwagon #2 – Foam Bad, XYZ Good

I sear the anti-foam crowd is hilarious (yes even better that watching the Fiberglass & Cellulose installers spout of on why their product is better than the other one) with their half-baked logic trying to sell you on their view. Unfortunately they got a big boost by a study done by one of these individuals which amazingly came out saying that every other product out there basically doesn’t contribute to “global warming” except for foams.

The brilliant name for this – GWP or Global Warming POTENTIAL. As I reminded a few others “Heh, can we actually start with some real science first before vilifying products? Lest everyone forget the P in GWP is potential & looking at the way they calculate out the numbers they have over 50% of known error potential (to start with) & that is slated to overstating the issue. With that said, should the industry look at using less caustic chemicals – shoot yeah”

It really is pretty simple; all products have pros & cons, places they should be used & shouldn’t be used along with directions that need to be followed to install them properly. It is imperative that you find someone that knows why & how to do the work properly so you won’t be disappointed nor have any issues.

Bandwagon #3 – LEED is Bad

Depending on what you read, LEED / the USGBC is having a bad time & getting beaten up by a ton of special interest groups. Two of the main issues revolve around FSC certification and the Plastics Industry. I have got to admit, wood certification is not something I follow to closely nor know a lot about, but the first thing to consider is that this is an optional point & not a mandatory one which many don’t even bother going after (especially seeing there are easier points out there).

With that said I do know the paperwork required for FSC is a nightmare for many chasing those points, especially with the chain of custody. Do we seriously need a chain of custody for products cut & milled in the US or Canada? How many other items differ from the SFI that are moot due to the differences in cultures, locations, or the type of forest (i.e. a pine forest is very different from a rain forest)? What will it realistically take for SFI to be accepted to meet stewardship goals based on the location? Can the USGBC &/or has the USGBC worked with them (or others) to get there? That is what needs to be out there and sold to SFI, the loggers, the mills, the public and of course those in government.

Ahh the plastics industry & oh boy, did they freak out over one line item in the third draft (which wasn’t even in the final draft and is also a “voluntary point”.) Amazingly if it wasn’t for this firestorm they artificially created, the FSC issue above probably wouldn’t have garnered an Executive Order from Georgia condemning the USGBC on it because almost everyone before was on the “LEED is Good” bandwagon. Just like FSC issue, LEED does have a few things to work on, but the end result is probably that LEED is going to continue growing like before. While many “LEED lite” programs are hoping to pick up some scraps I don’t see it happening because once you use – well we are like… but… – you have lost.

Just like the insulation example above, or the heating one above that, don’t just believe the hoopla or blindly leap on the bandwagon, as you might just find out that you are in for a rough ride. There are good points and bad points to almost every choice there is out there – take a few & make sure it makes sense for you and what you want to accomplish. Ok, I am stepping off the soap box now…

Related posts:

Remodeling Right: A Hedge Against Changing Technology
Common Sense Building: Radiant Hydronic Heating
Common Sense Building: Designing for Everyone (Interior Checklist)
Common Sense Building: Making Sense of Radiant Heat (FAQ)
Getting the details right: 4 biggest roof flashing errors to avoid
Fixing an Architectural Nightmare
My Take: Location, Location, Location
BS4D: Envelope Leakage Testing 101

Common Sense Building Tagged: CSB

Featured Posts

Preventing or fixing frozen water pipes

Updated: This article was originally posted in early 2010 after the Alabama Department of Health issued the following warning via press ...

Read More

BS4D: Ice Dam’s, Icicles & Attic Condensation, Oh My…

BS4D: Ice Dam’s, Icicles & Attic Condensation, Oh My…

Living in Arizona, I used to love traveling up to Flagstaff especially during the winter months. One of my favorite ...

Read More

February – Winter Maintenance Checklist

February – Winter Maintenance Checklist

Ahhh February, we are now in the second full month of winter and many people in the northern states and ...

Read More

Common Sense Building: Build Radon Out

Common Sense Building: Build Radon Out

As many of you probably already know, January is National Radon Month. Just like CO, it is an odorless & ...

Read More

FAQ: Humidifiers - To humidify or not…

It’s that time of year again when the air is drier which can lead frizzy hair, static shock &/or for ...

Read More

FAQ: Ceiling fan direction - summer & winter

One of the biggest questions out there is which direction should my fan be running and how can I tell. ...

Read More

FAQ: Should I close my crawl space vents during winter?

FAQ: Should I close my crawl space vents during winter?

In short the answer is generally yes, they should be closed up during the winter months. If you follow our ...

Read More

Random Glossary term

  • First Hour Rating

    The First Hour Rating (FHR) signifies how much hot water should be available for use when using a standard water heater with a full tank. Not only does this take into account the tank size but the recovery rate. This number is typically found on the upper right of your “Energy Guide” sticker. Heat pump & “instant” […]

Copyright © 2019 · Going Green Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in