The HTRC

The Homeowners & Trades Resource Center

You are here: Home / Wordless Wednesday / Wacky Weds: Building Collapse

Wacky Weds: Building Collapse

This is the full video of the Toll Brothers townhome development located in North Carolina that was taken by Ed Braz of Ed Braz Wildlife Photography who wrote about the experience here.

8

This is a follow up picture taken WRAL which had a few statements from the builder & inspection department. Unfortunately it appears that there will be no big investigation into the exact cause. The building department officials that did investigate, simply stated that it appeared that all the bracing & sheathing wasn’t fully up before the storm hit.

1

Interestingly Toll Brothers blames the entire issue on not having windows installed, metal framing & other structural supports. “Structures that are in such an early phase of construction…are not capable of withstanding the extreme (80+ mph) winds that were encountered on Saturday.”

2

To some extent they are correct on buildings in there early phases, but not having structural supports or required bracing up at the phase it is at… Based on the video, trying to blame a lack of sheathing was not an issue as the building that started the whole deck of cards from falling was the fully sheathed portion.

3

4

5

Of note though, one has to wonder just how well nailed the sheathing was based on the next few images:

7

6

Notice the full piece of sheathing – while this & some of the other pictures are doable based on wind blowing & pulling on the structure (yes it can rip sheathing off in full sheets) it really does make me wonder even more if they did follow the proper nailing schedule & maybe when they rebuild if they may consider using some adhesives in conjunction with nails. As a reminder nails are superior when it comes to shear, but not to pull out forces.

On the good news front, it is a good thing that no-one was around, especially work crews. Secondly, as stated by WRAL “Although there were six other units in a different portion of the same building further along in construction which did not sustain a loss, Toll is retaining an engineer to confirm that their structural integrity was not compromised by this recent storm.” After seeing this, I sure would want a few items checked.

Related posts:

Wacky Weds: Gutter Tree?
Wacky Weds: You have to be kidding me
Wacky Weds: Penny Wise but Pound Foolish
Wacky Weds: Ingenious light switch idea or hack?
Wacky Weds: A case for shims...
Wacky Weds: Can Fiberglass ever be...
Wacky Weds: Baffled
Wacky Weds: Speed drying
Tweet

Filed Under: Wordless Wednesday Tagged With: Advanced Framing January 15, 2014 By SLS

Comments

  1. Building Moxie says

    January 16, 2014 at 10:27

    nice report Sean. I am seeing on fb where some of the guys are suggesting that the sheathing was tacked up but did not have its finish nailing. interesting place to leave a structure under construction. and just cool that noone was hurt.

    • SLS Construction says

      January 17, 2014 at 09:54

      Thanks for chiming in JB & the kind words. I definitely thought of that one as many times they will have a crew that does nothing but nail sections off, but for the stage it was at with the presence of a WRB… I just don’t know & unfortunately it doesn’t appear we will ever know

      • Building Moxie says

        January 17, 2014 at 10:15

        that’s a good point with some of the WRB coming off in a heavy wind prior. Oh! someone missed a walk-around and a house wrap crew being boneheads. ha!

  2. Building Moxie says

    August 4, 2020 at 19:05

    nice report Sean. I am seeing on fb where some of the guys are suggesting that the sheathing was tacked up but did not have its finish nailing. interesting place to leave a structure under construction. and just cool that noone was hurt.

    • SLS Construction says

      August 4, 2020 at 19:08

      Thanks for chiming in JB & the kind words. I definitely thought of that one as many times they will have a crew that does nothing but nail sections off, but for the stage it was at with the presence of a WRB… I just don’t know & unfortunately it doesn’t appear we will ever know

      • Building Moxie says

        August 4, 2020 at 19:08

        that’s a good point with some of the WRB coming off in a heavy wind prior. Oh! someone missed a walk-around and a house wrap crew being boneheads. ha!

Featured Posts

Holiday Checklist – The day after

First off, we hope everyone had a great Christmas and are looking forward to the New Year. Many people will be heading out today for the annual gift exchange / ...

Read More

January is National Radon Month

January is National Radon Month

Should you be worried? Believe it or not – this is actually debatable by some people. According to the EPA, they estimate that there are over 21,000 lung cancer deaths per ...

Read More

January - Mid Winter Maintenance Checklist

Welcome to the start of a New Year, and the first full month of winter. This is the time of the year when many individuals try to wipe the slate ...

Read More

FAQ: Should I close my crawl space vents during winter?

FAQ: Should I close my crawl space vents during winter?

In short the answer is generally yes, they should be closed up during the winter months. If you follow our Monthly Maintenance Schedule, we recommend the month of October as ...

Read More

FAQ: Do I need to change my HVAC filter monthly?

FAQ: Do I need to change my HVAC filter monthly?

If you follow our Monthly Maintenance Program, the first item we have listed is "Change out your HVAC filter." This has brought up a few questions, namely: Do I need ...

Read More

FAQ: Exterior HVAC units - Should I cover my unit, or... fall & wintertime questions

When it comes to the exterior HVAC unit most people wonder about hiding them and reducing the amount of noise. We delved into that topic in our Spring & Summer ...

Read More

FAQ: Ceiling fan direction - summer & winter

One of the biggest questions out there is which direction should my fan be running and how can I tell. You look at the switch and realize it isn't any ...

Read More

The HTRC - Copyright © 2006–2023 by TheHTRC.com & SLS Construction & Building Solutions LLC http://SLS-Construction.com