Ten Rules of Roof Design: Really?

Just like clockwork, this last Friday Martin Holladay posted his weekly blog article under the by-line of Musings of an Energy Nerd on Green Building Advisor. While I generally am always looking forward to seeing what he has to say, I was particularly looking forward to reading this one on Martin’s Ten Rules of Roof Design. While he made quite a few good points (no surprise), and I learned a lot more about his growing up in the trades (i.e. as a roofer), there were plenty of items in there I just couldn’t help but shake my head at.

Granted Martin was providing these “design rules from the perspective of a roofer.” Unfortunately though, he might have forgotten that he is “the Energy Nerd” and some people might forget that he was only looking at it through roofers glasses (i.e. no call backs for leaks or other issues that may appear to be the roofers, but aren’t). It does appear that both of us do have some “strong opinions on roofs. So without apology, I hereby (respectfully) present my opinions…”

1. Avoid Valley’s

I have no arguments on “try to design a roof without any valleys. Valleys concentrate water and often clog with ice. It’s far more common to have leaks or ice dam problems near valleys than in the middle of a simple sloped roof.” While we rarely have to worry about ice down here, one of the biggest issues with them is that the leaves are rarely cleaned out, which leads to either dammed up water & areas which are just soaked.

As for the main cause of the issue- namely “designers” & mistaken beliefs that one must have a cut up roof to make it interesting – I would have to agree & disagree. Yes some architects go overboard, whereas in other cases they are necessary based on the land and a handful of other factors.

Popping up to a little earlier in the article I noticed he mentioned under mistakes he sees “shingle roof with a badly woven valley between roofs with different slopes. (When the roofer isn’t paying attention, these woven valleys tend to drift to one side.)” Actually the biggest mistake I see is doing a woven valley in the first place – a far better method (which is also more forgiving) is using valley flashing & trimming the shingles back.

2. Just say no to dormers & skylights:

Um wow, I guess I see why he added a preemptive comment section directed to designers at the bottom. As a simple rule I agree that the less complicated a roof is, the lower the chances are a problem may happen later. From a zoning, health, lighting, height restrictions, and even yes a design perspective, dormers, skylights, and solatubes do have their place.

3. An unconditioned vented attic is better than an insulated roof

If Martin is only talking only about vented attics vs. a vented insulated cathedral, this would make sense. Unfortunately this was not fully clarified, and I would argue that a Hot Roof Assembly will trump either of these options almost any day of the week, especially if one tops it with a “cool roof.” Below are my thoughts on his 4 reasons:

  • Reason 1A: Rafters aren’t deep enough – well maybe if one hired an architect & not a designer who knew what needed to happen, this wouldn’t be an issue. Besides even in a retrofit situation one can always add foam on the outside as Martin so points out in another article.
  • Reason 1B: It’s cheaper – Most of the times yes, but that depends on the structure, and if you are talking about a properly air sealed attic with baffles or just one where they blow & go. Along the same lines, while it may be cheaper up front, over time it probably isn’t, especially if there any mechanicals up there.
  • Reason 2: Oh my favorite one, “If you leave your rafter bays uninsulated, it will be easier to locate roof leaks.” Really, it is easier to spot an issue while tromping through 12” to 18” of insulation? How many times have you found a roof leak exactly where it shows up – maybe 10 or 20% of the time? While we are at it, just how bad are the roofers up in the North country? I swear almost everyone up there sounds like every roof is going to leak and there is nothing one can do to prevent that.
  • Reason 3: It is easier to air-seal an attic floor than a cathedral ceiling? I would dare say with all those issues with ice-dams up north, reality says otherwise. Either which way, one actually has to get someone to do it properly the first time which I would say is a challenge almost everywhere.
  • Reason 4: Damp roof sheathing will dry out quicker – true but why is it wet in the first place? As Martin so nicely points out in the article mentioned above (1A) “While roof ventilation can help dry out damp roof sheathing, it’s essential to limit the flow of water vapor escaping from the home so that the roof sheathing never gets damp in the first place.”

4. The best roof shape is a simple gable or hipped roof

Very good points, though I would add that wide overhangs are an issue in many area’s that experience high winds. If at all possible you want to keep your overhangs at 2’ or under (16″ or less for high wind areas) and base the size of them on the location of the sun during the winter and summer. If your overhangs are too large, you just might be blocking that winter sunlight that will provide you some free heat.

5. Don’t reduce the slope of your roof halfway between the ridge and the eave

For all our neighbors to the north, he makes a good point as you do have snow loads to be concerned about. For those of us in the south I would basically recommend ignoring this advice for the most part, especially if you are planning on having wrap around patios to help control the sun light & reducing the associated heat load and allow for the windows to be opened. If you are planning on this though, going less than a 3/12 for the patio section is just asking for trouble and you will need to clean that area off occasionally (leaves, needles, Frisbees).

6. Asphalt felt makes more sense than synthetic roofing underlayment

Sorry, let me try to stop laughing… its cheaper and allows the wood to dry to the exterior… Ummm, did we forget the other item above it which is basically another vapor barrier, and since when is cheaper better? I do agree that if you are going to be cheap, 30# felt is a better option. Personally if I am going to go with a less expensive option, I will stick with a minimum of I&W on all the seams & edges of the roof. (Drying in the Roof)

7. Plumbing vent pipes should penetrate the roof near the ridge not near the eaves

No arguments from me, just let’s not get carried away & place them where they interfere with the ridge &/or have issues with the air flow coming off that area. (Code requires all vents to be a minimum of 6” above the roofing & 6” above the height snow would normally accumulate)

8. Choose metal roofing or asphalt shingles

Granted I understand and it is re-clarified that this is just an opinion & he does list some good pros & cons not only here but in other articles – but for longevity, rain water harvesting, and numerous other factors an individual should really think carefully before just going – I’ll take shingles or metal. There really are some good reasons why concrete tiles are used so much in many southern areas of the country, slate up north, etc… My top two choices in many areas would be a concrete tile over a hot roof assembly or if one was going to add solar panels – a standing seam metal roof (they have clips that attach to the seams, thus no roof penetrations).

9. Get flashing details right

AMEN & nice trick on using cedar shingles with step flashing and asphalt shingles – I might have to try that one day. Now if we can only work on the issues with drip edges… (well at least down here)

10. Anticipate ice dams

Fortunately I don’t live that far north, but as one would expect, he does give some great advice

5 simple principles:

In short (and because this post has gotten so long), I think Martin made some good good points & items one should consider, but calling them rules is a stretch. From a roofer’s perspective, there are 5 key points or principles every architect or “designer” should keep in mind;

  1. The simpler & steeper the better; try to minimize or eliminate valleys, dormers, changes in pitch, and penetrations
  2. If you have a complication in the design, design the “fix” to last and not fail (see valley comment above for an example)
  3. Choose the right materials and flashing solutions based on the house, the climate, location, and potential future uses or plans
  4. Don’t forget to anticipate other potential climate or location specific problems and design accordingly (high wind, snow, sun, lots of trees/ leaves, disturbed attic insulation in northern climates)
  5. Think like a drop of water does; it doesn’t matter which materials you use if they are installed or spec’d incorrectly – so design those problem areas flashing & details right from the start, as going back later is a lot more expensive