The HTRC

The Homeowners & Trades Resource Center

Brought to you by:

You are here: Home / Insurance / Construction Defects: An Owner’s Perspective

Construction Defects: An Owner’s Perspective

chris-hillThis week I would like to welcome Mr. Christopher Hill whom I have had the pleasure of meeting via Twitter approx. 4 years ago. I have always been impressed by Chris’s take and advice on legal and policy issues that affect construction professionals, especially as it relates to “green” building. This was ratcheted up a few years ago, when he made a big leap & went solo so he could specialize in this arena even more. One of the other things that he does that is different is that he opens up his Construction Law Musings blog every Friday to other professionals. I have had the pleasure to write three pieces so far & am honored that Chris agreed to me flipping the table on him & doing one for us. So with no further ado, the official bio & article…

Christopher G. Hill, LEED AP is Virginia Supreme Court certified mediator, lawyer and owner of the Richmond, VA firm, The Law Office of Christopher G. Hill, PC.  Chris has been nominated and elected by his peers to Virginia’s Legal Elite in the Construction Law category on multiple occasions and is a member of the Virginia Super Lawyers “Rising Stars” for 2011 and 2012. He specializes in mechanic’s liens, contract review and consulting, occupational safety issues (VOSH and OSHA), and risk management for construction professionals.

Christopher-Hill

First of all, I wish to thank Sean for the opportunity to post here. I would also like to invite you to check out his latest Guest Post Friday post at my Construction Law Musings blog for a great read.

This week Sean has asked me to “muse” on the topic of construction defect claims from the homeowner’s or building owner’s perspective. While these types of claims are generally discussed separately from breach of contract claims both involve some form of poor or non-compliant construction by the general contractor or one of its down line subs. However, the two types of claims are separated by one key factor from a practical perspective: Insurance.

Most contractor commercial general liability (CGL) policies do not cover standard breach of contract claims, leaving the Owner without an insurance company to pursue for any monetary loss. This limits any recovery possibilities to the assets of the general contractor. On the other hand a “construction defect” claim for damage which includes other parts of the home or commercial building allows (with some exceptions beyond the scope of this post) for recovery against a (hopefully solvent) insurance carrier.  This can be a key factor because, particularly in the residential context and in this economy, the general contractor may or may not have the monetary or physical assets to satisfy any judgment or other claim.

Additionally, being able to claim a “construction defect” for damage to other parts of the building caused by the poor construction performed by the general and subcontractors opens up the possibility of additional non-monetary damages under certain circumstances and potentially opens up the insurance coverage of all of those contractors that performed work.  As is always the case with construction claims, the more pockets an owner has to collect from, the better.

In order to avoid being limited to a breach of contract claim, an Owner generally must have damage to other parts of the building or home that are not a part of the contractor’s specific scope of work.  This is for two reasons.  The first is that the poor construction itself will likely be viewed as a breach of contract and nothing more.  The second is that most (if not all) CGL policies specifically exclude from coverage damage to the work of the contractor or subcontractor that allegedly caused the damage through its poor performance (the “your work” exclusion).

Therefore, a typical construction defect claim would need damage to other parts of the home or commercial building for the key insurance coverage to kick in.  For example, poorly installed and leaky piping that causes damage to the drywall and causes mold to grow would lead to a possible construction defect claim that brings in all insurance coverage’s that would apply to pay for that damage.

From an operational perspective, and Owner must notify the General Contractor of any possible defects immediately.  The Owner should do so in the manner required by the contract if possible, but certainly do so in writing.  CGL policies have claim timing requirements (i. e. notification within x days of knowledge of defect), so the faster the General Contractor and its carrier are notified the less likely that any claim will be excluded from coverage for a timing reason.

The Owner should also do what it can to avoid further damage so as to avoid a fight over whether the Owner did anything that could have made the issue worse.  The Owner should do those repairs that will stop the damage while documenting what the issues were so that when the claim is made, the proof is there.

Of course, all of this very general discussion is subject to state law and the specific exclusions found in the policies themselves.  I also highly recommend that any owner consult with a construction attorney in its jurisdiction to discuss the various avenues of recovery when faced with such a situation.

Thanks again to Sean for the opportunity to post and I look forward to hearing any comments on this discussion.

Related posts:

Mortgage Loans Tips & Tricks
The Rationale for Getting 3 Bids?
Insulating your Basement
Review your Policy now; before you need to file a claim
Insurance Claim FAQ's
Tuesday Tip: Check your Insurance Coverages Now
A Look across the Pond: Basic safety rules while working on-site
A Guest Rebuttal? Not Dead Yet! Saving the Pot Light
  •  Tweet
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Filed Under: Insurance Tagged With: Guest Article's February 15, 2013 By SLS 13 Comments

Featured Posts
Composite & Vinyl Decking – 10 common enemies to avoid

Composite & Vinyl Decking – 10 common enemies to avoid

While we love building wood decks, many customers are opting to go with composites & vinyl decking materials due to the reduced maintenance that is involved. There are a few ...

Read More

Taxes, Record Keeping, & Clearing the Clutter

Taxes, Record Keeping, & Clearing the Clutter

Oh no, it’s April 16th and taxes were due… are due on the 17th? (Sorry folks in 2022 & heh it is now May 17th - yeah Covid) In reality, ...

Read More

April – Spring Cleaning / Maintenance Checklist

April - Spring Cleaning / Maintenance Checklist

April is the first full month of spring, and shortly the kids will be getting out of school, everyone will be heading out on vacation, and it seems like our ...

Read More

Safety Sunday – 20 reminders for grilling

Safety Sunday – 20 reminders for grilling

In 2009 alone, over 16 million new grills were sold and a study showed that 82% of the US owns a grill with 97% of those owners admit that they ...

Read More

Getting ready for Spring: Your deck & grill

Hopefully, this last snow storm was it for spring (really?) meaning most of us can start getting ready to grill and get back to enjoying the great outdoors. Needless to say for ...

Read More

FAQ: Ceiling fan direction - summer & winter

One of the biggest questions out there is which direction should my fan be running and how can I tell. You look at the switch and realize it isn't any ...

Read More

Common Sense Building: Build Radon Out

Common Sense Building: Build Radon Out

As many of you probably already know, January is National Radon Month. Just like CO, it is an odorless & tasteless gas; however, unlike CO there are no warning signs ...

Read More

FAQ on Duct Cleaning: All Hype or Worthy Expense?

It must be spring time... I got the following in the mail just the other day: 5 different ads all for duct cleaning. With allergy season starting along with my ...

Read More

Random Glossary term

  • ERV

    This week I would like to welcome Mr. Christopher Hill whom I have had the pleasure of meeting via Twitter approx. 4 years ago. I have always been impressed by Chris’s take and advice on legal and policy issues that affect construction professionals, especially as it relates to “green” building. This was ratcheted up a […]

The HTRC - Copyright © 2006–2021 by TheHTRC.com & SLS Construction & Building Solutions LLC http://SLS-Construction.com